
I finally started reading "Pushed" by Jennifer Block. I've had this book in my library of books to be read for a few months now. Like Marsden Wagner's book, "Born in the USA", this book looks at the medical mis-management and downward slope that our healthcare system is doing all in the name of progress in obstetrics. I found myself nodding my head, once again (like when I read "Born in the USA"), at what I'm seeing in the OB field.
- Active management of labor
- Overuse of induction agents
- Overuse of c-sections
- Denial of a woman's right to VBAC
- Use of cytotec without true informed consent
- Lack of true informed consent about ANYTHING in obstetrics
- "Pushing the pit" to the point of fetal distress
- OB's "saving the day" by performing emergent c-sections - caused by their own mis-management of care and messing with mother nature
- Non-baby friendly hospital care
- Separation of mother and baby
- Putting hospital policies above all else
- Fear of litigation
- Not listening to what women want
- Not asking what women want
- High epidural rates
- Non-support of laboring women by competent birth attendants
- Doulas being laughed/forced out of the labor ward
I was chit-chatting last night with a fellow nurse who believes in the power of a woman's body, natural childbirth, birthing without fear, etc. We both feel sometimes that we are powerless in our position as L&D nurses to enact change to the flawed "baby factory" system that we work in. But, it's not always true - we CAN enact and enable change - one mother at a time. One baby at a time. One birth at a time.
We can speak up for what our patient (mother-to-be) wants and desires for her birth experience - because it truly is HER BIRTH EXPERIENCE. We educate women on the fact that cytotec is not FDA approved for induction of labor, when we have them read and sign the consent prior to it's administration. Yes, sometimes (more often than not) the woman says she doesn't care about it - she just wants her baby delivered NOW. But it's our position, as L&D nurses, to educate women to the best extent that we can, about what their doctor/midwife wants to do to them. They have every right to know.
We advocate on behalf of women, to prevent them from falling victim to the cascade of labor interventions. We refuse to "up the pit" to the point of fetal distress. We provide as best as we can, one on one physical and emotional support during the labor process. We encourage women by telling them "you ARE doing it!" when women say "I can't do it".
We work directly in the "baby factory" and help women, one woman at a time.
We join councils at work to enact changes to policies and procedures.
We review literature and studies for the best care of women and their babies.
We work our asses off, to the point of physical exhaustion, to help a woman birth her baby in the way she wants it to happen.
We shoo the obstetrician from the room, when he/she brings negativity into the room by saying things to us like "she won't be able to do this, she's going to be a c-section." Then we turn around to the woman and tell her, "you CAN and WILL do this - let's prove your doctor WRONG!"


18 comments:
I really wish you could be there when I deliver my baby. I need you to tell me, "I AM doing it!" and encourage me through every contraction to NOT get the epidural. Any chance you could come down to Bethlehem in May?? :)
The world needs far more L&D nurses like you. Thanks for making a difference.
I agree with everything you wrote except that you refer to the laboring mother as a "patient" when, in fact, she is a client. She is not sick, and by referring to her as a patient you lump her in with everyone from the cancer patient to the patient with a broken leg.
She's a laboring mother, she's not broken and she's not sick. She's just havin' herself a baby ;)
Thank you for being a maternal-infant advocate in the factory!!!
Wonderful posts, would that all L&D nurses were as awesome. Have you seen the Business of being Born? Really something I recommend. Find a screening with a panel of experts discussion afterwards... or offer to be one of those experts for a screening near you!
you dnow how I feel!
Dawn
One small voice can drown out a thousand others... if the right person hears it.
To those mamas you serve. You are that voice. They probably don't even know how lucky they are!
Don't underestimate the power of that one woman spreading the good word after she has had the informed birth she wished for. Bless you for making this difference.
I finished Block's book a couple of days ago (also loved Susan Diamond's book.. Hard Labor). I am a new L&D RN who was a doula in the same unit where I now work (hospital employed). That makes my hospital sound progressive but it's not... 39% C/S rate last month.
This book makes me angry and sad and motivated and bummed out that I work where women are so under-educated and frightened that a Dr. who thinks he knows best can tell them they even though their labor is progressing fine they are falling off the Freidman curve and that they need "some help". They need some help alright....
Still I go back day after day to usher in these little ones and hold their mommy's hand because I hope that I am making a difference for someone, even if it's to explain why they have to have a C/S that they probably wouldn't have needed if they had been allowed to labor on their own.
I LOVED the book Pushed. I couldn't put it down. It totally changed everything I know and understood. I am such a strong advocate for natural birth now.
I really enjoyed PUSHED. It combined interesting facts with some memorable birth stories. I hope you will enjoy it.
BRAVO for being there and doing what you are doing!!! As I said in a comment under a different topic, I don't think I could cross train to LD because I just don't believe in so much of what I already do. But you are a gem and those mothers need you! I can't wait to read Pushed!
Really?
I am sitting here with my OB texts open and needed a break and stopped by to read your blog, and this is so sad to read.
Do you really think so badly of all OBs?
Maybe I'm half tipsy from the two 20 hr days I just worked in a row, but how can you honestly say we are all bad?
I did a crash section on a pt today who's midwife let the baby brady down to a HR of 60 for over 30 minutes. 30 whole minutes. Are we still evil? Who did more harm here? Who?????
Do people forget giving birth used to be the most dangerous thing a woman did in terms of a health risk? I totally agree there are docs who over intervene a LOT (a lot!), in fact I work with some of them. I am not one, and it is sad then when I actually DO need to do something (see above), I get lumped in the same category.
I hate it that people ignore the fact some of us work our ASS off so we are smart enough to know when to let well enough alone, yet be prepared to spring to action when needed. I haven't seen my husband once this week. I work and I study so I know the evidence, know the facts, know what works and what's crap and more harmful. In my heart of hearts I know I help, encourage, and am there for my pts if they need me to be, and my goal is first do no harm. And a lot of us ob's DO work that way more often than not. It's just so inflammatory to categorize a whole field. I think today's the day I take this blog off my favs.
Sorry to ramble, I'm so tired.
we're not all bad. Back to the books.
You have a link to my blog here, so I felt I could comment although I have never commented before.
Birth plans and the whole "birth experience" thing have much less focus in Europe. Do you know what would be on my birth plan if I had one:
1) Nuchal cord = c-section
2) Choice between my life and the baby's - please save the baby first.
That's it.
My first born was stillborn after a problem-free, text book, low risk full-term pregnancy, with plenty of monitoring. He died the day before my scheduled induction, before the onset of labour, 4 days after my due date. No medical cause could be determined. I don't blame the standard of care I received, which was very good and I have stuck with the same OB who has a talent of remaining professional whilst demonstrating compassion.
I fully agree that women should be informed about the drugs they are given, and the procedures which are happening and why they are being followed and this should apply to any type of medical intervention.
However, I don't give a crap about "my" birth experience. "My" experience is not the top priority here. The healthy delivery of my baby, alive, is what is important. Me coming out of it alive and healthy is important.
Delivering a dead full term baby is the only experience I had. If only I could get back the missing shared lifetime with him, then how insignificant this moment would be.
VBACwarrior is wrong...when you sign up for a hospital birth you become a patient. You are not sick but you have signed on for healthcare and that comes with some give and take. you give us some time on the monitor, we give you some time to walk, shower, rock, breathe, whatever you feel you cannot do on the monitor. sign on for a hospital birth, play by the rules of the hospital. If you want a home birth...it can always be arranged.
that being said...at your cervix, you're right on a number of points. although I'm sad that you work with OBs who are so negative...and I have found that here we (RNs) have a great deal of input on the care of our pts. one woman at a time is the only way it can work for now at our institution. I love working nights in that I have a chance to whip out my research and say...x,y,z...while the residents try to sort out our research from the attendings' beliefs (I've found that sometimes the resident is a better pt advocate to the attending when armed with nursing research...it works better than the OLD OBs going solely based on anecdotal evidence)...
It's too bad we live in such a litigious society...I think sometimes the MDs need to be empowered, too. We as nurses follow policies and use our best judgement...as long as we do we're usually "safe"...the MDs struggle with what is best for the patient and what will be least likely to get them sued. If the fear of legal action wasn't so prominent on their minds they might be more willing to try more holistic practices...
I'd love to read the book! I may have to add it to my list...
Brava to you, and all OB nurses who feel like you do. I think you are a dying breed. Keep up the great work - you are doing the right thing.
A question. What would happen if a doctor wanted me to have a c-section for "failure to progress" and I refused?
Could they kick me out of the hospital? EMTALA would seem to require that the hospital keep me. Would they have to get a court order to do a c-section?
I'm about half way through Pushed and it's fascinating--although I wonder if I should be reading it while 26 weeks pregnant.
evil hr lady, the answer is yes, they would have to get a court order. Of course, you could always leave and go to another hospital in the meantime.
Post a Comment